Home | About Us | Breaking News | Archives | Contact Us

   

SIGNIFICANCE OF MALBAR-07 IS NON ALIGNMENT OVER FOR INDIA? YES IT IS AND LEFT OBJECTS

Ranjit B Rai                                                 IDU Update (September 2007)

One of the largest five day multilateral advanced Naval exercises, ever to be held in the Bay of Bengal with 27 warships and 200 aircraft from five nations, took place from 4th September, away from the gaze of Indian citizenry. The Government decided to keep the national media away from the Indian naval platforms in view of the left parties opposition to the exercises, and the 123 nuclear deal. However the US Navy embarked selected Indian media with full facilities to transmit their electronic dispatches, and made much of the spectacular event. Three aircraft carriers, the nuclear powered USS Nimitz( borrowed from the Central Command by Pacific Command and loaned From Iraqi Freedom) and the aging Kitty Hawk ( to be defence commissioned), displacing 80,000 tons and covering two acres each, with F-18s, E2C Hawk Eyes operated alongside India's 27,800 ton 47 year old INS Viraat with Sea Harriers. INS Viraat was joined by eight Indian Navy warships which included the Kashin-Rajput and Delhi class destroyers. Vice Admiral Douglas Crowder Commander 7th Fleet based in Japan and India's Eastern Command Chief, Vice Admiral R P Suthan a navigation specialist, embarked on the carriers as witnesses during the exercises, with other observers from the Indian Navy. Rear Admiral Robin Dhowan Flag Officer Commanding Eastern Fleet shared responsibilities as OTC- Officer In Tactical Command, with the two US Battle Group Commanders on the carriers, and Flag Officers from Japan, Australia and Singapore who were embarked on their flagships for Malabar-07.

OTCs, during their time in command of the exercise bear the tactical responsibility to control all the communication circuits and order the tactical maneuvers, firings and formations, in standard operating procedures SOPs which are worked out in advance, labeled the Allied Tactical doctrine. The Indian Navy inherited the British ATP which most western navies follow and hence naval exercises are easy to adapt, and all communication operators speak in English. For the duration of the exercises the US Navy extends the a basic internet MTP protocol that enables the participants to become net centric, to ensure common operating tactical pictures being displayed in the ships nerve center called the Ops Room in the Indian Navy, and Combat Information Center CIC by other navies.

The three big flat tops with their top gun pilots were joined by US Navy's nine front line destroyers, and Singapore's latest French built La Fayette class frigate RSN Formidable, which possesses latest stealth features and hosts compatible net centric warfare systems and the deadly Harpoon missiles. Australia fielded HMAS Sirius and support ship Adelaide and Japanese Self Defence Maritime Force under Fleet Commander Admiral Yoji Koda flew his flag on Destroyer Oonami and Yudachi. US Navy's nuclear attack submarine USS Chicago and an Indian Navy 1500 HDW class submarine simulated the under water threat in the ASW anti submarine warfare drills. The armada of the five countries at sea, formed what is being described as a 'cooperative strategic group' working up to achieve the aims of inter operability, and India's Defence Minister A K Antony assured that there was no intention to ascribe any other reason for the exercise, and conveyed this diplomatic message to China. The tonnage at sea during Malabar totaled 350,000 of lethal nuclear capable arsenal, with over 400 loaded surface to surface SSMs, and anti air missiles and torpedoes supported, by 200 war planes and helicopters flying from platforms and ashore. Indian Navy's Maritime Reconnaissance MR ASW capable aircraft TU-142, the largest all up weight platform in the Indian Armed Forces, operated in support of the ships from INS Rajali at Arkonam, and were joined by Japanese MSDF and US P3C Orions which operated from Meenambakam, both airfields near Chennai. Indian Air Force maritime Jaguars which are capable of attack at sea operated from shore and it was reported were easily intercepted by the F-18s. Regretably on the last day of intensive flying one Sea Harrier ditched while landing but the pilot ejected safely.

The planning for this multi national exercise had been done on war footing in advance, and Admiral Timothy Keating Commander US Pacific Command from Hawaii, had visited New Delhi earlier in August and explained how he had specially borrowed the USS Nimitz for Malabar -07 from the Commander Central US Command. The Nimitz was on its operational patrol off Iran, in Iraqi Freedom. India comes under the Pacific Command while Pakistan is under Tampa Florida based Central Command for liaison purposes, which also oversees the war on terror in Iraq and Afghanistan.

It is notable some 13,000 uniformed naval professionals from five countries jostled with each other at sea in war games, embarked each other, cross decked planes, flew in each others helicopters and planes, and exercised interoperability and anti terror moves. The ships also exercised the controversial Proliferation Security Initiatives (PSI) with boarding of ships for nuclear inspection. USA is pressing India to sign the PSI and hopes to forge a Framework for Maritime Security in the heels of the brief, but wide ranging land mark Defence Framework that then Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee signed in Washington DC with Donald Rumsfeld, in the Pentagon in September 2004. In recent times the Indian Government has consciously accorded greater emphasis and support to the Indian Navy, for its ship building and acquisition programmes, which includes two aircraft carriers, nuclear and conventional submarines and 30 ships.

The 17,000 ton LPD Landing Platform Deck INS Jalashawa (ex USS Trenton) with 6 Seaking SH-3 helicopters under Capt B S Ahluwalia, silently without any fan fare that normally heralds such an arrival, transited in to the Bay of Baengal during Malabar to be based at Vishakapatnam. The Jalashawa has a Raytheon supplied Phalanx AA battery and updated Shrike 32 EW equipment and can carry a battalion of troops and 12 tanks and landing craft and its decks can operate Sea Harriers. The question after Malabar-07 could well be. Is this the last straw that may break the back of India's avowed 'Non Alignment' policy, that still breathes ? There is speculation that USA, Japan, Australia and India are acting as a 'Quad' for security cooperation, but what the Indian Navy has gained in professionalism and confidence is what Malabar-97 was all about.

Cmde( Retd) Ranjit B Rai is a former Director of Naval Operations and Intelligence and Vice President Indian Maritime Foundation.